Mail Bag Update 4/15/08
I'm so mad at you I would like to strap bricks to your feet and throw you in a river.I'm mad that week after week I have to listen to that screaching like a cat in heat country fried crap Kristy! would rather have a root canel they listen to her.Remove this site or face the coniqunces you filthy rat infested donkey ass.Fuck you and eat hot death you bastard.
-Adrien
I don't know why I am writing this because you don't deserve any of my time, and you are probably going to post this on your website and fucking gloat about it, but I feel so strongly and angry I am going to anyways. Let me start by saying that I used to be a fan of your site. I felt you gave fair and entertaining recaps, and I enjoyed reading them so much that I ignored the fact that I hated the idea of voting for the worst and the fact that Taylor Hicks won this competition. I was even a Sanjaya fan thanks to you(although my votes went to Blake.) I began to become less enamored with your site as your recaps became less enjoyable and you criticism of Michael Johns became less comprehensible. Then Thursday night's travesty occured and your sheer thrill and delight that an incredible singer and performer was voted off before that joke Kristy Lee Cook drove me over the edge. Michael is in NO WAY a "song stealing douche" and for you to call him one with out even stating yours reasons is incredibly sociopathic. I truly believe now that you are the destruction of this show. American Idol has gone from a perfectly respectable television show that actually showcased up and coming talent into a piece of fucking shit joke do to your abominable site. I hope you discontinue this farce, and look in the mirror and see yourself for the sociopath you are...
-Arielle
Wow I dont even know where to start I hate this site so much and the people who created it! last year, yup I'll give u credit, it was funny watching sanjaya scream his way through the top 12, but this year you guys have gone way to far!!! This is easily the most talented group of contestants so far and you guys just wanna tear them all down!!! and then, someone as awful as Kristy Lee Cook,you support!!!!! I know you think it'll be cool for someone bad to win but it wont be!! Thoose people have real talent and genuinley want to be there! Kristy Lee Cook is horrible and the only 'fans' she have are the people who actually follow the bullshit on your site. You guys are pathetic. Probably fat losers who just sit at their computer everyday writing shit about other people cuz your own lives suck that bad. Jason, The Davids and Carly and Brooke all deserve to be there! PLEASE grow up and stop promoting Kristy Lee Cook! America cant stand her and its because of you assholes thats she there!
-Tia
I hate you guys!!! Michael Johns was the best singer on that show and because of you guys, Kristy stayed and Michael left. I am Australian and he represented us. I am so mad with you guys. It is horrible what you do to these kids. You make fun of them when they are up on the stage in front of EVERYONE singing their hearts out. This is so sad. You should be disappointed of yourselves. You have stopped people from winning this show just so bad people could stay in. This is sad and I wish there is a way to stop it. If there is… let me know. This is the worst website I have EVER come across. THIS MUST STOP NOW!!!!
-Carly
Dear Pathetic Dweebos at VoteForTheWorst.Com, Ummmmmm hello? Do you have a life? I don't think so. If you did, why would you feel the need to put others down? Kristy Lee Cook is such a horrible singer and she isn't even entertaining in a bad way. She just jumps around singing lame-o songs and wearing clothes that are to provocative for family television. So yeah. Whatever. You know who's good? Carly smithson. So there. She's going to win and you are going to cryyyyyyyyyyyyyy, Sorry I had to go there. xoxo (NOT)
-Ariel
Clearly, Brooke White, or Kristy Lee should have been eliminated this week and discerning viewers know that to be true! Your mockery of a show with entertainment value that appeals across the masses is pathetic. Your sole goal seems to be to sensationalize your ignorance and make a name for yourself.
Michael Johns was a definite final contender and would have made it to the last three finalists. Our pick to win is David Archuleta and he will compete with David Cook. Instead of doing what you do, why don't you get a real job and stop duping the less intelligent members of the public who support your stupidity!
-Dome
LOVE YOU GUYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Idol would suck without you!!!
-Pat
Just wanted to share how funny think that most of the people so angry with you can't spell worth a shit. And MAN, are they angry! They're gonna shut you down, man... Anyway, I enjoy it. Gives me something to have fun with while my 12 year old makes us watch it with her.
-Caryl
How can you call this an anti-american idol website and tell people to call and vote for someone? To vote, people have to watch and find the right number to vote on. Both the ratings and the votes perpetuate the show. I know my one email won't get anywhere or make a difference. But you all are retards. If you want rid of something, DONT BE A FAN! One day you'll find out the only people giving the show ratings and keeping it on the air are you retards who are calling in and 'voting for the worst". That show doesn't care if you vote for the worst, as long as you vote, theyre getting their cut. Quit hanging off of simon's left and sucking on his right..
-Kristina
If you guys want to do something constructive this year, why don't you figure out a way to get creepy David Archuletta off my TV screen. The kid creeps me out with the way he licks his lips and stares into the TV screen. And since he has been deemed the second coming of Kelly Clarkson, you'd think you guys would hate him the most. So instead of just voting for the worst, vote for everybody but David A. and send him and his annoying stage Dad home.
-Carole
david archuleta is the worst. Period.
-Karen
I check your site periodically and find it humorous, and am definitely glad you guys are out there. Although, I must suggest that David Archuletta is a care bear, and has to go because he's giving me a damn toothache. Anyway, I support your cause because the producers have way too much input (Kristy Lee on tour FTW?), and too many stinkers stay along for that generic feel (Jason Castro's one trick has been done to death).
That said, I found tonight's results show to start out on a nice OFFENSIVE start. I have no problem with people singing the lyrics to their song choices, whatever it may be about. This especially comes out in more religious songs (though if Kristy Lee does Amazing Grace one more time I might kill someone), as well as during country week (Dolly's Jesus references were annoying, but they are classics, so I'll live). Starting off your Idols singing "Shout to the Lord" was just plain offensive. Obviously because the show is run on News Corps's baby it's got the potential for right wing propaganda. I had no idea that the Christian right was picking out the songs now. To force all the contestants to sing that crap to an audience that has a large amount of non-Christians was BS. It's "Idol Gives Back", not "Idol's Christian Mission". Just because many of the great volunteers of our time have been there on behalf of religious groups (Mother Theresa much?), doesn't mean that everyone who volunteers or gives must love Jesus. There are Jewish, Muslim, Hindu, and Buddhist groups that all give time and money to people, but you never get a song for them, much less flat out propaganda. "We did good, praise Jeebus!!!" Sing crap like "We are the World" or something. I didn't turn on TV for Thursday night sermons.
Honestly though, we know that there are other parties at work when liars like Carly Smithson and no-talent-pretty-face people like Kristy Lee and Castro (even if they did have good weeks) stick around.
-Seth
I think this site is beyond stupid. I had to check it out though and I see that you have put a lot of effort into screwing up a TV show. Why? Don’t you have anything better to do with your time? If you hate the show so much, don’t watch it. I am having a good laugh at you though…..being as how you can’t find any ONE contestant to single out! All the contestants are good this year. All I can say to you is that if it were you competing, would you want people trying to humiliate you? Evidently, you must have been raised in a family where there was no respect given to anyone. Such a shame. I do agree though with one thing. I do believe the judges tend to pick favorites, and try to sway the vote towards that person. But, then again, is that not what they are supposed to do? All three judges have succeeded in their own businesses and they know what sells records and makes money. And yes, it IS a popularity contest! Duh!!!! If it wasn’t, only the three judges would decide! I would suggest you close this website down and quit doing something negative…..try to do something positive. Hey, why not try to help raise money to send to the American Idol Fundraiser “American Idol gives back!”
-Ken
I was wondering if you guys caught Brooke in her big lie this week. A few weeks ago she had a big segment talking about how naturally talented she was and that she taught herself to play piano when she was 4 years old just by hearing a song - she could replay it and she just knew where the keys were. This week she mentioned that her piano teacher was in the audience.
-Adam
Kristy Lee Cook should not have been your pick because she wasn't the worst contestant. Michael Johns was the second worst singer in the top 12 after Amanda Overmeyer and this proves that you have no idea what you are doing. Michael Johns is the one that could have messed up American Idol. I laugh at you and your attempts to screw American Idol up because you can't since you don't know who would mess up AI the most.
-Vincent
So, I wrote a couple of weeks ago, defending VFTW's right to criticize, but criticizing them for low blowing Carly and for having too many ads.
Well VFTW-ers....I TAKE IT BACK!
Do whatever it takes, keep this site running! People need to be exposed to the truth! The more I read about Carly (and Kristy Lee for that matter), the more I become disgusted! These ho's (haha now I am stooping to the level of the haters..sorry!) had labels and record deals before Idol! I thought this show is supposed to be about finding new blood, the best of the best of the "up and coming" not the best of the worst of the "tried and failed"!
Okay, my apologies again, I went a little "!" happy...(but at least i can admit it.)
But seriously folks...take it from someone who started out hating this website, then understanding it, then appreciating and finally now supports it...
I have attempted the idol audition process. It is unfair, biased and totally ignorant. I have been singing my whole life as has my friend that i went to auditions with and we didnt even get a chance to sing-- for anyone. They told all these people to show up (for publicity) after they had already given out all of the possible "audition slots" to people like Carly "Smithson" and Kristy Lee Cook, who have already had their chance.
But don't feel bad for me...think about all of the people out there who have amazing voices that just never got the chance because they didn't know how to break in or didn't know the right people or couldn't afford to move to Cali. And then, these girls who've had their chance coming bouncing along and STEAL that one chance away from them. That is who you should be feeling sorry for. Not the Carly's of this world. in other words, way to go vftw!
-Hilary
I know, it's hard to think you are the smartest people in the world. You know more about music than any of the people on Idol. Even though they are rich and you are not. If it makes you feel better to call people scumbags for trying to have a singing career, then more power to you. I've been the smartest person in the room before and outgrew it. It just fills you with anger and resentment.
-Lisa
__________________________

Awwww. I <3 ADB frautards.
__________________________There's a fine line between not listening and not caring. I walk that line everyday. - Private Leonard L. Church
Tia said "...Thoose people have real talent and genuinley want to be there! Kristy Lee Cook is horrible and the only 'fans' she have are the people who actually follow the bullshit on your site..."
Does that mean that Kristy does not want to be there? Then why did she audition?
She must have had some fans prior to being the VFTW pick, or she would not have made it into the top 12.
I love these tamper tantrums lol.
I used to be a huge fan of American Idol at the beggining, but lately I watch it and the only thing that's exciting for me is waiting to read the blogs on this site the next day. I love you guys!
All that hate over a TV show. Priorities in life cease to amaze me.
ETA: Dave you filthy rat infested donkey ass.
__________________________Before The Music Dies
Paulas-Cup-O-Drugz wrote:
I'm gonna start a new topic today, so look for it!
I strongly urge you to re-think that. ItsMeDeb
Ok, first I'd like to say that the letter from "Arielle" was not me posting under a pseudonym. I swear!
She has some anger issues, but one valid point - Michael is NOT a song stealing douche. (Or any kind of douche, period, but douchey-ness is in the eye of the beholder I suppose.) After reading your original post about him and all the allegations, I did further research and found out that it's not completely true. I posted my findings in another thread, but no one really cares because, as someone put it in that same thread, you guys already hate him and don't want facts to get in the way of your reality. And it's cool if you hate him because you think he can't sing or you think he just seems like a dick. Everyone's entitled to their opinions. But, if you're going to smear his name with some sordid song-stealing controversy, you should really go all the way with your research and make sure you have the full story.
Of course, I would never have cared enough to bother to look further into this issue if he wasn't so blazingly hot. I have no problems admitting that I'm ruled by my hormones.
Aaaanywaaay...I still love this site and I don't blame you for sending Michael home last week. That was a producer's stunt. AI's ratings are going to go way up this week, no doubt.
I'm kind of glad he's gone in a way because now I can fully embrace the side of me that loathes this show and everything it stands for. Yet I still can't stop watching.
__________________________Idol recaps and inane pop culture ramblings - http://thepopeye.blogspot.com
I enjoy sensationalizing my ignorance. It's my right as an American!
I also occasionally enjoy feeding coniqunces to my root camel, looking at my sociopathic self in the mirror, being a fat loser sitting in front of my computer typing s--t about people all day, being disappointed of myself, wearing clothes that are too provocative for family television, not respecting my family, having no idea what I am doing, and outgrowing being the smartest person in the room.
Thank you, Mail Bag, for helping me define myself as a person!
__________________________http://notbaio.wordpress.com
"Let me start by saying that I used to be a fan of your site."
How can anyone be a fan of this site and yet take the show so fucking seriously?
Proving once again that there is no limit to stupidity.
(although I bet *some* of those expletive-laden diatribes have been penned by Worsters....they are too funny!)
__________________________http://www.dj-mc.com
Non-cheesy Karaoke DJ Entertainment in Sacramento
VFTW Rocks DJ MC Karaoke Entertainment
You know, I hate a big plate of cold death... I much prefer mine to be piping hot.
__________________________See more of the Wacky World of J-Mo at http://blog.myspace.com/jman987654
Carly - Yes, you can take us down!
http://voteforthebest.weebly.com/
Go there!
__________________________MyBowlAd - MySuperAd