Brooke White is the New VFTW Pick!

I've been lurking around for a few days, but I must say, I really want Jason to walk away with this

Seacrust: "Jason, YOU....are the new American Idol"
Castro: "Whhhoa, haha confetti. Wait uhhh...haha WHOA! ...Huh? Haha Ryan Seacrest, why are you hugging me?"

Hell yeah. But despite Jason not being picked as the VFTW pick this time, this could be a good thing. I am in full support of getting Carly "my husband has NO emotion and claps like a robot" Smithson and Syesha (she's way too boring and lame to even make fun of) out before crazy Brooke. I'm still saving some votes for spacey Jason, but I'm in full support of Brooke as well. I want Brooke to be the only female left when it comes down to it so that she'll freak out and have no roommates and have to talk to herself which will further her spiral into complete insanity.

"You have a uniqueness that's all your own, and that's you. If you stay true to yourself, then you'll be you."
-- Paula Abdul's words of wisdom

i like DA when he first sang heaven for auditions. I feel sorry for his vocal condition at first cos i can still hear him gasping when he talks n sings. Than after all d tweentards, fagtards, over 40 mumtards, pedotards started filling in, on top of d incessantly over-pimping by TPTB and dull snoozefest songs he choose every week, i jes don care for him anymore. Maybe he should get some tips from our timeless VFTW robbed AI winner, d mighty sanjaya!

penggy the penguin

Here's hoping that Texas A&M gets Jason Castro as one of their army brat Yell Leaders. Whoop!

I would vote for Brooke before Syesha or Carly, so go Brooke!

Yeah the girlies and old ladies like him, but so? He is just a kid himself and you can't blame him for the fans, liking him. Yes the screaming annoys the h3ll out of me, but I say good for him!
If this was a REAL competition, a nice clean cut singer like him would be a good role model for the kids, of course I am the last one to be talking about role models =P-- but I heard once 20 years have passed [since you were in a band] there is an unwritten rule about accumulating street cred for being an 'old rocker' -- haha. I think david cook will be the one this season to make the pop album that will sell. His voice is very commercial and just the right sound for this time period. Jason will cruise the coffee house/college circuit; syesa will act; brooke will take time off for 'rest' at an approved mental rehab facility-- maybe see her first R rated movie--lets hope she stays FAR away from kids from now on; Carley will go home to her native country and get on irish idol or whatever they have there.
If dave A wins I will not be that upset-- I barely even care for this season and I am more jazzed over Battlestar Gallactica than AI right now.

Constantine FTW!

Well done. Now let's work on getting her and David A. to the Finals. Can you imagine what joyous TeeVee that would be? Both would be on the verge of tears, Brooke because she's a whackjob, David A. because his Dad is waiting off stage with a wire coathanger.

Plus - Mormons don't drink Coke, so that would be a wonderous marketing boo-boo for TPTB.

And to the haters who claim that making Brooke our pick is mean ... we call her Brooke, not Crusty Shitstain. That's going easy on our new IBW.

WWSS: What Would Sanjaya Sing?

I LOVE Brooke, and actually, I'm VERY happy she was VFTW's pick! She would be done if it wasn't so. And I think she is more "loony" than crazy, but whatever, anything goes as long as we vote for Brooke! \o/

P.S.: Yes, the judges are way more mean to her than the VFTW site.

The judges absolutely TRASHED Jason on Larry King - they don't like him at all. He would be the producers nightmare if he won.

I think Jason is the person who would be the absolute nightmare to the producers if he won. They don't like him AT ALL. The judges (especially Randy) trashed him when they went on Larry King. I think Jason is the only one that is left that they wouldn't be okay with winning. I expect him to be kicked to the curb this week so he'll get voted off.

On a differant note, I think Brooke is just as emotional and has just as much nerves as everybody else - she just is an open book while the others probably hold it in until they are off stage.

Ha! Excellent answer!

Karaoke Gokey blows.

I would have been happier with Jason because he is more entertaining but Brooke was my second choice, so I'm in.

Karaoke Gokey blows.