I have really had it with this stupid site your the reason good people get voted off like daughtry jennifer hudson constantine & the reason why bad stay like scott makayla sanjaya taylor. All really need to get a life bad all are the reason why people think idol is rigged i seen on msnbc where all vote for people like sundance until he imporved stupid motherfuckers brian duckelman needs to give life also reason his ass was kicked off was b/c he is an ass he is just plain & no presonaliy. Corey Clark from season two is a flap flopper one second he saids idol is fixed & other he saids he was it was amazing journey he needs to get a life i don't care how many lies all spend about idol it will be around for another Five or six seasons. I know all where so disapointed when thoese kids where voted off of the next great american band poor brats.You think this show will get idol off the air you really crazy. You suck dick really bad vote for the best.
-Michael

First of all, why would you make fun of someone for being a douche when you are one yourself? Michael Johns was better then that hick mess Kristy and if i had the chance i would shoot you and throw you into the canal! Michael Johns and Carly Smithson are better then Sanjaya will ever be and i know you'll post this on your fucked up site, but get this, You weren't making a difference. AT ALL. Only about 1/100 of the voters voted for shit singers because of you. Hell, even Sanjaya thought you went to far! And Sanjaya only made it far because of the Girls that voted for him that thought he was "Adorable". So I suggest you end your site right now. P.S: Carly isn't going to go anywhere anytime soon.
-Gregory

hey! i love your site and read it all the time, anyway i just read the bit about ryan dunkleman claiming idol is rigged and i wanted to send you an email and tell you that - while i don't have proof that idol is officially rigged - i do have some very good supporting evidence that makes dunkleman's story a lot more believable.
do you remember in the fall when fox ran 'next great american band'? which was created by the SAME people as american idol. (19 entertainment SIMON FULLER) and produced by nigel lythgoe... same guy as american idol. the clark brothers ended up winning... and later went on to perform on idol this season. i happen to be a very close friend of one of their other brothers (they come from a HUGE family). before the show even started, he told me that they were picked to be on the show and the producers told them straight up, "we're guaranteeing you a spot in the top 3... and pretty much you'll be the winners." so all of the other 9 bullshit weeks of competition and everything else meant NOTHING because the entire time, they knew for certain they were going to be the winners. which also would mean audience votes meant nothing. they're very nice, humble guys and i'm positive that their reactions were 100% real, but they also knew very well the entire time that they were going to be the winners.
also, they previously were part of a country group called 'the clark family experience' with the rest of their brothers in the early 2000's... which would propose the same problem american idol is having this season with 'talent previously under contract'. also another band in the competition, 'sixwire' had previously held a recording contract and even had a song out on country radio in 2002 called 'look at me now'... coincidence that they came in 2nd place on Next great american band? i think not.
i mean, i can't say for sure american idol is rigged but i'm just sayin, that is what i know about next great american band... and it was created and produced by the idol masterminds... soooo... you can almost be certain that someone in this top 6 that are left was told from the beginning, 'we guarantee you a spot' and text/phone votes mean basically nothing. all i ask is that if you use this story on your site, please don't use my name haha. i don't want to be sued or anything, i can't afford that!
-Anonymous

You ruined American Idol for me.  I’m not even watching this year. To keep from having singers who would tank they brought in the ringers who already had experience. Your picks go home... Now... you have ruined it for yourself too. Get a life.
-Lynda

hey fuckers  you lost again give up  fools  becouse you fags dont matter anyways  vote who ya want fools amanda  where is she lol  .  GIVE UP FAGS   .  From the bigman
-Ace

Lovin' ya more each year. May you continue to remain a thorn-in-the-side.
-D. Beck

It says in 2004 you started your game-playing “Vote for the Worst.”  However, no one even heard of you until 2005 - Season 4.  I really don’t know why you take credit for Scott Savol (5th place – Season 4).  You didn’t have a following then so your votes didn’t matter.  Like everyone has told you already.  You had absolutely no part of Season 3 (YEAR 2004) – Fantasia’s season.  You weren’t even around then.
And I really wouldn’t take credit for Kevin Covias – Season 5 (11th place) and especially Taylor Hicks – Season 5 (you taking credit for Hicks is laughable).  Everyone wanted Taylor Hicks and he had a huge fan base without your help because he was a white male, and a white male hadn’t won yet. 
I will give you credit, however, for Antonella Barba – Season 6, who came in 15th (wow, slow down “Vote for the Worst” – you’re making a great impact) and Sanjaya Malakar – also Season 6 – 7th place.
So in essence, you get your “picks” up to 11th place on average.  Not 5 like you insinuate in your website.  If that’s the best you can do, then so what.
-Donalyn

What is wrong with you people? You're ruining the whole concept of american idol.
-Sofie

I just don't understand this website at all!You guys say that American Idol isn't about finding talent,but just about making a good reality show!You might think that in your own sick little mind,but your so far from the truth!
Why do you want to destroy a talented person's chance at winning American Idol by voting for another person who has no talent and doesn't deserve the chance?
Well,I'm guessing the person or persons responsible for starting this website are unattractive wanna be rock star loser trolls who can't get laid,with no life,a small penis and have a burning desire to be famous.So you latch onto the coat tails of American Idol,cause that would be the only way idiots like you could possibly get the publics attention.
Or maybe YOU were a contestant on American Idol during one of the first seasons and the judges laughed at you and said no,cause you have no talent.And maybe Simon was especially mean to you.So maybe this website is based on revenge and obviously much jealously!
I've been knowing about this site for a long time,but stepped over it on my journey through cyber space......just like I step over piles of dog shit when I am walking outside.I had no desire to even write you a letter till now.Its one thing to vote for a loser,but when you start trashing the Idol Gives Back show,that's when I felt a need to write you!
So,what's wrong with people trying to help others less fortunate???
I'm doing fine now,but I have been in the ranks of the less fortunate in the past.I am a survivor of Hurricane Katrina.I lost EVERYTHING and had to watch people I love die,while I was helpless to do anything!If it wouldn't have been for organizations like American Idol giving money and helping.....well,I don't know would have happen to me!
You trash American Idol's efforts to help people by calling their program "Idol Gives Head"(which is something I'm sure YOU never get!) Then you turn around and support The American Cancer Society!I see your still hanging on tight to American Idols coat tails!So when are you gonna do something ORIGINAL that is not connected to American Idol???
Whatever the reasons for this website.....I think is sad and I truly feel sorry for you.All those emotions of jealousy and hatred bottled up inside! Why don't you channel those emotions in a positive way? Do something to help your country be a better place to live,instead of subjecting it to such a negative jealously driven website! THE QUEEN HAS SPOKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
P.S.I'm guessing you will not have the balls to put this letter on your website?
-Diane

You all are idiots. Get a life and a job.
-Kristen

Might I make a suggestion as to the new "Worst" contestant ? I regularly post on a message board where some friends of David Cook participate. The general consensus is that David would be best served by hanging around until the top 3 or so, then losing so that he doesn't lose control of his career. Why not push for David to actually win the whole thing, to the end that his dreams of rock stardom are crushed at the hands of the bumbling corporate clowns at American Idol. Sure, he may actually be the best, but imagine a 5 year contract to churn out mind-numbing "product" choreographed by the A.I. puppetmasters. Brilliant!
-Jerry

You should be ashamed of yourselves for stealing spots from really talented people , but what can you expect ,only a bunch of low lives can think about things like this instead of making something to better our country , way to go america,what a great future we have.
-Silefer

Everyone who gets on this website and posts how extremely upset they are, you have my pity.  I don't want to shock anybody, but its a TV SHOW.  You idiots treat it like its your freaking religion!  Crying over someone getting kicked off the show is something that should upset America, because it shows how pathetically sad some peoples lives are.  Why get upset?  Everyone on this show will have a chance to put out some kind of cd or mp3, so save your change and you can buy all you want from itunes.  Keep on keeping on VFTW! 
-Ronnie

EVERYONE MUST VOTE OFF DAVID ARCHULETTA - HE SI SO LAME AND SUCH A NERDY BAD SINGER
-Yourigloo

Dropped by your site to see what you're up to this season to mess with the results...
Clicked on the "Carly Smithson" link, only to find what creeps you people are.
I don't buy any of your "holier than thou" reasons for trying to affect the results.  You people are nothing more than hatemongers, pure and simple.
I'm well aware of all the corruption that takes place in these so-called reality "talent" shows.  I've worked in the TV industry for many years, and have seen it all.  But take away all the greed of the producers, and you're still left with what is essentially tens of thousands of young people with big dreams, hoping to get a shot at what's nearly impossible for most to achieve.
Out of those thousands, a few rise to the top, and get the exposure that had mostly eluded them until now.  Some of these few are genuinely talented, and have a gift they are willing to share with us, the audience.  Once in a while, we get to see the very beginnings of the making of a true star.  That's what keeps me watching year after year.  I love to watch the metamorphosis from nobody to Celebrity, especially when the new star is deserving of it.  And by deserving, I mean talent-wise, and ONLY talent-wise.
I'm not interested in whether or not the contestant had previous failed record deals, or gave lap dances to gay men or bared their titties on the web.  I could care less if one slept with Paula or another used to jam with Randy, etc.  What matters -- and all that should matter -- is whether or not they are TALENTED enough to sell records and fill concert halls, period.
Reading your string of snippets attacking Carly Smithson reveals you people for what you are -- vermin.
This girl can sing circles around the other contestants.  She can hit the low notes with finesse and gusto, and I've yet to hear any girl on this show, from any season, including Ms. Clarkson, who can belt out a Celine Dion song or Annie Wilson lick as good as the originators.  She truly has star-level talent.
Yet all you mopes can do is try to trash her and call her horrible names like "Cunty" and "ho," and for what reason?  She's ambitious and wants a music career?  Guess what?  She DESERVES ONE.  She's got everything it takes, and for whatever reason, you cannot stand that.  Is it because you lack that gift yourselves, so you have to tear down those who are blessed with it?
At the end of your life, what will you have to show for it?  What will YOU have accomplished?  I truly hope it's something more meaningful than pouring hours upon hours of precious time into destroying the dreams of others.  Now THAT'S a life one can be proud of... not.
I agree with you that there is corruption in these reality "talent" competitions.  But it is NOT necessary to trash and demonize the contestants to make your point.  Their only crime is daring to dream that just maybe they've got what it takes to make it in the big leagues.  Spreading hate towards the contestants only serves to delegitimize your "cause," such as it is.  You only provide content for other hatemongers like yourselves to feed off of.  You only show yourselves to be hypocrites when you criticize American Idol for exploiting the contestants for commerical gain, for isn't that EXACTLY what you're doing with this site?  You are exploiting the popularity of the show and its inherent flaws to make your website popular... which rewards you with commercial gain.
Release the hate, the anger, the jealousy, the fear.  Learn to forgive, beginning with yourself.  Only then will you start to see your world from a higher place.
-Scott

__________________________