Well, I gotta say that I am surprised....I REALLY thought that our dear Tat would get thru to the top 12 (13), if for nothing else but the drama.

I fully expected AI to use her every week as the last pick for the last available chair as the weeks went on. For the first time this season, they surprised me.

Problem is, we now have a very boring top 13, which is what I thought AI wanted to avoid at all costs. Strange days, indeed.

Roostah

Tat sounded better tonight than she did the first time. I was annoyed that she sang the same song too, just because I knew that she was shooting herself in the foot. Shit, shit, shit.

Oh well, I'm sure Megan and Jasmine were already decided on well before they even sang. I doubt our little diva had a fair shot.

GREAT re-cap of a predictable episode... It is a massive shame about Tat. She was quality.

I really am a Tatiana fan and was outraged by how poorly and unfairly they treated her. She out sang everyone and they refused to give her good reviews but gave the worst singer ever to make the top 12 (Megan) good reviews just because Simon wants to do her. I’m joining today to say “Fuck you American Idol, I want my revenge.”

I think the next pick should be MICHAEL SARVER! People on here aren’t naming him because even VFTW fans hated that he got through. Everyone knew he sung poorly and all the fans hated that he got through including me. Think how pissed people would be if we got Michael Sarver to the top 8! The producers would be pissed and know the format was a mistake because people like him wouldn’t have gotten through on last year’s format. Simon would feel like a major dumbass for telling everyone to vote for him (I think he’s already started to). People who voted for Michael are moving their pity votes to Scott and don’t want him through anymore. Michael can also do funny things on stage.

People like Adam, Scott, and Allison are going to make it far and you can vote for them later. No one’s going to be pissed when they make it farther because they’re already expecting it and they want it. You’re helping the fantards if you vote for them now. Don't ever pick Megan either because the judges LOOOOOVE her no matter how horrible she is. They want her to go as far as possible.

Everyone is expecting Michael to be the first one out but think how funny it’d be when he survives even if it’s just one week. All we have to do is beat the last place person because only one person is going home.

Are you Michael Sarver?

Are you on permanent copy paste or what - you posted the same post on the other thread.

Michael must be desperate for votes if you're trying to round them up on VFTW, although he is a worst for sure.

Tatiana not getting through is depressing...but expected. You KNEW the judges and producers were just using her for ratings and didn't want her in their precious top-umteen.

I'm probably most disappointed in Ricky Braddy not getting through. I mean, really, this guy can sing, and never once got any love or screen time...why, because he had a NORMAL background? Sad times indeed.

I have no idea who the next choice should be. Everyone is so bland in their own way. The only person who really stands out as an entertaining persona is Adam...

I was Furious but at the same relieved because I think Tatiana is too Good for the show!

She has more entertainment and talent value in her fingernail than AI could ever hope to EVER get!!!

I did like the fact that paula called her over and comforted her and told her she is going to be a singer and an actress!

I am officially jumping the AI ship! I will however come to VFTW for highlights and all the hilarious banter!

Oh Yeah and whats with there only being like 10 members to the tatiana forum?!?!?!?! on her .com???

EDITED TO ADD................I LOVE MY NEW HILARIOUS AVATAR!!!!! I AM SOOOOO KEEPING IT!

"Simon says that Tatiana picked the song 3 times, and Tatiana corrects him by saying she’s only sang it twice. Simon also asks if Tatiana would sing the same song every week, but seems to forget that Kristy Lee cook sang “Amazing Grace” 5 million times and still got through."

I just went back and checked all of the recaps and saw that Anoop did My Perogative during Hollywood week, yet no-one called him out on it this week. I guess the same song rule is as arbitrary as the forget the lyrics and go home rule.

Yeah, I suddenly love Paula, I think she showed class when she consoled Tatiana. Actually, Paula's been very good this season, lotsa times I thought she made the most sense out of all the judges.

On the other hand, that fugly Kai Kalama(?) is an asshole.