Final 11 Results: Post Game Analysis

I was pleasantly surprised with Carrie's singing. I think the judges weren't really ever going to use their veto -- they're waiting for a week when the chorus line forgets to vote and Adam needs saving.

Alexison's death knell was when they put our Megan into the mix. She was no longer the eye candy (she never really was, but only in comparison to what was there before.) I think we'll see more personality from Allison and Anoop, and several of the others have already shown a proclivity for humor -- intentional or not.

This top ten does not nearly have the talent level of the last few years, but is definitely VFTW-worthy.

Alexis was boring and dull.......forgettable in every sense of the word.......See ya!

AHH bye bye Allison-Alexis. Hello Caw-Caw.

I have found a new sport. It involves getting on a message board, not AI official, but regular ones like MSN's comment section after they recap the show, and saying something negative about Gokey.

Wow, it's like the funniest shit to see how many emotional fuckwits there are out there. Jesus gets defended less.

Someone made the comment that not liking Gokey = no musical taste. Then me and Music went and cried for the sad state that AI has brought people to.

As I said in a different thread - I believe this was AI's way of upping the 'drama' - wow, shock exit from someone we really thought was going to be Top 4. Sorry producers, most of us never considered Asexis a contender, especially after her performance the other night. But America will lap it up and it will make the show more 'controversial' which means more ratings. Personally, I think we need another shock exit please. Dead Wife please.

Bottom line - Asexis took Lady Tatiana's place in the final. She was tainted. She's gone. I'm glad.

I'm not sorry to see Sarver go by the way - beefy guys are far and few between on this show so keep him around as long as possible please - woof. I mean, he's a doofus but woof.

<p>

Hey Psychobabble,

</p>

<p>

Can you post some of the funniest responses here so we can enjoy them together?

</p>

<p>

And also, how did they defend Gokey's horrible performance this week?

</p>

<p>

&;nbsp;

</p>

<p>

Best wishes,

</p>

<p>

Chan

</p>

So that insider reveals the planed final 4 so they sweep in to discredit the credible report! My conspiracy theory....

I didn't watch the results show. I never really do, but I have been this season for Scott. Good thing I didn't miss anything spectacular.

I kind of thought earlier on that Alexis would have been one saved by the veto. They're holding on to that puppy for Lil I guess because I can't see DWD or Adam with the lowest votes before the top 5.

I wonder if that chick who "knew the top 4" feels like a douchebag now.

How dare Mr. O'bama have a press conference on a Tuesday night during Idol season?

Worsters are so simpatico! We seem to be on the same page every week with analysis of the train wreck/addiction that is American Idol! The lip synching number sounded so strange because of the way the audio was tuned up. Did anyone else notice that? It was like listening to an old 33 1/3 vinyl record with the sound just coming out of one channel of the speaker. God awful! It also reminded me of the Brady Bunch number: "Keep on keep on keep on singing and dancing all through the night". The beat was similar and the choreography harked back to the Brady kids in their beaded fringy technicolor pantsuits. Was it Kris who lifted Megan up onto the piano in that number? They looked a bit nuggly. It would be great to be a fly on the wall in the mansion to see what type of hanky panky might be going on there! I wonder if the other contestants are thinking, "damn, Scott's on the tour and now we have to babysit him the whole time." Megan didn't even pat him on the back or anything when he sat back down next to her on the couch. Although she is a germ fest this week so maybe she's keeping distance. I do feel sorry for Scott. Does he really have an awareness of the bullshit going on around him? The producers may keep him there just to make him a laughing stock. If the judges had put Alexis back it may have put Sarver on the chopping block again next week. I bet he's so glad she's gone. The look on his face was so telling while he was sitting on the chair. He's too much of a wise Texan to not realize what contrived crap that whole show is. At minimum, he'll get a gig at the Houston Rodeo next year after it's all over. I'm glad Adam is still there. He really is hilarious. I do like how he just laughs right at the judges when they recap his comments. Maybe he's really in our camp! Ryan is such a tool! "Kieran bring the boom over". We will be a day later watching next week because of Pres. Obama. Does he realize how this affects the consciousness of the nation????!!!!!!

I don't think they ever intended to use the save. All that was just for drama in an otherwise boring show. Soon as Ryan sent Allison to the safe couch I knew the save wouldn't be used.