Your absolutely right. I respect that if he wants a private site, it's his too do. However, to open your site up to the public and then allow a few moderators to abuse the very rules you put in place, while banning others for doing the same thing is completely hypocritical.

I actually had enjoyed the site for a couple of years. The real problem started with certain moderators. There were even post about people writing him to complain about it, but he still defended said moderator. Quite frankly, she is going to be the death of his site.

In turn what has happened is what you stated. It's dwindled down to a few people who were sick of being chastised about things they said, yet the moderators were allowed to not be censored. This kind of "we can dish it out, but we can't take it" attitude is exactly what drove myself and several friends away from the site.

Well, I was banned. LOL. Sometimes you can only listen to certain peoples BS before you just have to comment. LOL.