This year really does have the least talented girls. They hype it up saying they're the best group of girls just because they want a female winner but the guys are probably better this year so they'll probably have to rig the finale to get their female winner.

Katelyn was the only one I was really impressed with and I didn't even think she was going to do good since what I saw in her audition and Hollywood was just average. Based on last night, she's the only one I thought could sell a lot of records.

Michelle's performance was way overrated. It was Alicia's version except removing almost all the high notes. I thought they were going to slam her for that but they didn't.

Lilly's performance was forgetable. They only said it was unique because her look is unique.

Haeley really earned her VFTW spot. Either that song has no tune or she removed it and her high notes are irratating.

Lacey's was the worst though since it had no entertainment value, was boring as hell, and was sung horribly. Her and Ashley will probably go home on Thursday.

Oh, I know I'm obsessing over Tatiana again but if Tatiana were on this season, she would've destroyed all of these girls vocally but the judges would still tell her she sucks and criticize her personality instead of talking about her performance.

Great review! I loved Haeley's performance, she was adorably awful. I, for some reason, cannot tolerate Siobhan or Katie, to me they're like nails on a chalk board.

And Ellen offered nothing tonight (except for the hot mess). She hit the nail on the head when she said that she couldn't judge on the technical stuff. No shit, then why the hell are you there? Dissapointing, because I like her as a comic.

Long time lurker, but wow! did this bunch of girls suck. EPIC FAIL, as much as I hate that expression. That bus was on a roll tonight: "Precocious", "Complete and utter mess", "Indulgent"...Simon's favorites when he's driving that bus LOL. But they were terrible. All of them. I have never seen such an underwhelming group. The most decent one was Crystal, but her attitude was even better. Oh, and I can't stand Katie Stevens one more second.

Note to, "E" when you are a judge you cannot have relations with the contestants. So calling Haeley a "HOt" mess was a bit of an awkward moment. Oh and by the way "E" I believe she is also under age and you should not be thinking she is so hot. I believe that is a crime?

Oh wait that performance was a crime and probably the worst I have seen on the show in years.

So my comment on Kaetlyn's performance- is it just me or was her singing whorish and not just her outfit?

I mean really it was like she was going for the teen male vote and any other straight guy out there. Only a few other contestants have been able to do the whorish singer well. It can take you far keep doing it and show more skin.

MrMoneybags

I can't believe the show actually wants one of these train wrecks to win. They seem like a bumper VFTW crowd to me, although only a few were bringing the necessary attitude, Crystal and Haeley.

I'm hoping that since he's a lame duck, Simon will bring the inner worster. He was good last night. They might as well have him sit next to Randy though cause I don't think he can stand Ellen or Dogface.

I still want to know why Katie Stevens thought this would be a good, relevant look for her:

Perhaps she thinks AI is a tryout for a new Disney production a la High School Musical. Sorry to tell you honey, but Disney owns ABC, not FOX.

Once again -- Dave (and Prof. Chan) have nailed it.

Haeley Vaughan is a great VFTW pick, because she has Fantards and she's sorta cute in a pug puppy way.

Here's hoping that she gets to stick around for a while.....although Lacey Brown is the worst singer of the bunch.

"I kept waiting for Ellen to say she didn't like to make toys and wanted to be a dentist." << that comment FTW! I thought same thing, Hermey lives and he is Ellen.

Here's hopes Haeley makes it to smile, smile, smile another week! Trainwrecks like that don't come along every day.

It IS VFTW's year - looking to be a free-for-all.