Top 2 Sing: Theme: "Who Cares? Just Vote For Phillip!"

Posted by Insane on Wednesday, May 23, 2012 at 12:10 AM EDT
Share:

Hello, worsters! Are you happy yet? This is the final week of the crap-on-a-stick that has been Season 11 of American Idol. Not only that but this week's performance show is only an hour! I suppose they're saving for when they run 493 minutes over during tomorrow's finale, as is the annual tradition. I'm going to help by jumping right into the performances.

Phillip won the coin toss and smartly chose to go second, so Jessica is up first with Simon Fuller's pick, "I Have Nothing" by Whitney Houston. This is appropriate, since they're milking Whitney's corpse in order to let another corpse sing. This is a typical Jessica power-ballad performance, which means that she had a few really awesome notes floating alone in a sea of boring. Way to coast, Jessica!

Oddly enough, the judges are being forced to STFU until the end of the round. Have they learned nothing from Paula's Season 7 gaffe, when she critiqued Jason Castro's song before he had actually performed it? Oh well, at least we get to jump right into Phillip's song, which is "Stand By Me" by Ben E. King, which Simon Fuller loves to give to people he wants off the show, such as Josiah Leming. However, Phillip is taking to the song like he takes to a Dave Matthews song, which he does by turning Stand By Me into a Dave Matthews song. None of the above matters, though, because I know the Phrauen are eating this up like it's a giant bag of Phillip-flavored, dick-shaped Cheetos.

Now it's time for the judges to uselessly weigh in. I guess the hour has to be filled somehow. J Lo starts with one of her 20-minute rambles without saying who she thought was better. This is what she gets 12 million dollars a season for? Randy gives the round to Jessica because his taste in music is atrocious, and Steven says nothing. Nigel, please shitcan these judges. You know you want to. And we know you have it in you to do it. Come on, man. For America. I mean...for your show and for your reputation in Hollywood. There, that got through.

Jessica starts Round 2, but not before J Lo gives the first round to Jessica, and not before Jason Derulo performs. I don't care about this, so I skip right to Jessica, who I also don't care about, but Jason isn't competing and Jessica is. Jessica's favorite performance of the season is "The Prayer", naturally. I'm trying really hard to put down my worster hat for her performances and not let my bias for Phillip get in the way. This is impossible as this performance is just really, really slow and sleepy. It would make an awesome lullaby, like something to get your cranky kids to sleep. She gives us a good glory note in the middle in order to keep the audience from falling asleep, and it almost worked.

Phillip's favorite song from the season is the far less sleepy Billy Joel's "Movin' Out". It's not much different from the last time he performed it, but this time there was Hot Sax Girl and more shit-eating grins from PP. Awesome! Steven gives Round 2 to Jessica to a sea of boos from the audience. Randy calls it even, and J Lo correctly gives the round to Phillip before Ryan cuts her off mid-sentence. Hey, how else are you going to humanely get her to shut the hell up? I love this format of hearing as little as possible from superhacks J Lo and Randy. Steven never says much anyway, so I barely notice when he basically doesn't talk at all tonight.

Now it's time for the coronation song round, the first nail in the coffins that hold PP and Jessica's respective careers. Jessica's song is called "Change Nothing", and I immediately want to change something - the channel. Not because it's Jessica, but because AI coronation songs are the worst songs ever written. Seriously, can you remember any of them aside from MAYBE "A Moment Like This"? Anyway, Jessica sings this piece of crap like she just learned the song yesterday, alternating between warbly and screechy. Seriously, if she was good, I'd say so, but this just stunk worse than a pile of Ke$ha's sweat-soaked party clothes left out in the sun. Randy said he didn't love the song, but she made the song more than what it was. Well, that wasn't hard to do, was it? It's a coronation song. J Lo liked how Jessica sung the song, but also criticized the song choice. Then she kept talking past her welcome point, as usual. OK, this must be why Steven doesn't talk. Oh. My. Gaw. She's still talking. STFU, J Lo! Steven also hated the song and probably wants it to die like the rest of us want it to.

Phillip's song is called "Home". Guess what the results show theme song is going to be next year? Oh, American Idol. You are so transparent. Phillip is singing now, and while it's not the best song ever, it's one of the best - and least cheesy - coronation songs in AI history, and it seems to have been written just for Phillip. It's not good enough to win any awards, but possibly just good enough to get heavy rotation on AC radio. PP gets a standing O from the judges, as well as some "WOOOOOOOOOOOO"s from Randy. Then, Randy says, "yo", and "dude" before verbally ejaculating all over PP. J Lo said it was "different", which I think means "Wow! You sang a coronation song that didn't turn you into a total embarrassment!" Steven said that Phillip is "the man". And we're done.

I'd like to thank Dave for giving me the opportunity to project my voice to this fine audience of dozens. I keep swearing that this is the last year I'll be following AI, but if any changes are made (like replacing all three judges, please, please), I'll probably be back for another springtime of torture.

Voting is still going on all over the country as of right now. DO NOT GET COMPLACENT, lest Jessica's rabid fans take over. Phillip's numbers are 1-866-436-5702/04/06/08. VOTE!

1 2 3 ... 4 next › last »
lady D28
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 12:38 AM Reply with quote

Whoever wins, just be glad for they will finally achieve their dreams. Both of them worked hard for this competition. Both of them gave their best. Cheers!

sassafrassy
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 12:50 AM Reply with quote
Location: Such Fun

My seven year old had a fit when Jessica came out in her opening dress.


She said, "Those boobies are fake, because she didn't have them last week. Besides if they were real, she would have that cleaver line thing on her skin."


Me: 'You mean cleavage?"


She also complains that Jessica screeches or mumbles but she never just sings. My 7 year old is a Jr. Worster.



Aussiebits
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:00 AM Reply with quote
Location: Tomorrow

"fine audience of dozens" Laugh


I used to watch AI if I couldn't be bothered changing the channel. I mean, really who cares in Aus, right? Then I discovered VFTW and AI is now mandatory viewing especially because we see it hours later and I watch while flicking through the PBP and yours and STP's recaps.


If this nasty mess is picked up again next year, Insane, you and STP better both be here or I shall sulk.

Vada
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:04 AM Reply with quote

gotta love the honesty of a child... I think Sanchez is a 13 year old with fake boobies as well... she has no body therefore probably no boobies... maybe worsters know someone who can uncover the age fraud... that would be HOT! I want to know when vibrato and screeching became singing or pleasant to listen to???????????? Part of this is the judges fault as they kept ovating Joshua for coming unglued on stage and as they did it just got worse..... it created a sickening season as the contestants that COULD sing were voted off for the screech clowns. P2 did not buy into any of it and I applaud him for staying who he is and standing alone. Good luck to him tomorrow and in the future... as someone who had 16 kidney stones in one year I applaud his will power to keep going.


LKsMum
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:24 AM Reply with quote
Location: Philippines

Quote "sassafrassy":


My 7 year old is a Jr. Worster.



Let's have a playdate for our kids! My 5 year old is a Jr. Worster as well. She falls asleep even before Jessica opens her pie-hole. She is now hounding her closet to wear grey clothes from today until the weekend to show her support for PP.


She used to be a huge Colton Dixon fan but she switched camps when Mr. DICKson didn't even bat an eyelash when I tweeted him my daughter's fan photo for him... :(



Phillip Phillips for the VFTW Victory



Last edited by LKsMum on 5/23/2012 at 1:39 AM
S3Indiana
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:31 AM Reply with quote
Location: Sorrento Hills, San Diego CA

Think that voting 1-866-436-5709 would work for none of the above...

Legend
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:39 AM Reply with quote

Insane, your recaps are so insanely funny, I have been thoroughly entertained by each one! I've been going through some heavy personal stuff so I needed a good laugh and you delivered! Thanks!


Let's all hope that P2 can make it all the way! Keep dialing/texting/emailing/skyping/sending carrier pigeons, everyone! Let's go America!

pimentochz
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:45 AM Reply with quote

Phillip's song sounded very similar to something by Fleet Foxes like "Mykonos" or "Your Protector". Even Grimace knew it. I suppose if you're going to rip someone off, there are worse sources to choose from. Just made me wish I was listening to FF instead of PP.




LadyHeather
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 1:46 AM Reply with quote
Location: Your sweetest nightmares

Quote "Aussiebits":
"fine audience of dozens" Laugh


If this nasty mess is picked up again next year, Insane, you and STP better both be here or I shall sulk.


^^^What the kitten said, STP and Insane! I thanked STP in his thread, and wanted to be sure to thank you to for the funny recaps, Insane. All season. I know it's got to be a lot of work, and we really appreciate it. You two died for my sins these last couple of weeks so I did not have to watch the shows. But, you could tell me the coronation song was the Horst Wessel Song, and I'd believe you, since I refued to watch any more, so my gullibility is in your hands. While I trust you, I didn't need to, to know I was voting for P2 like crazy.


Phil will be accepting the crown tomorrow from the emergency room no doubt. Not from his kidney stones--but from being sick of AI.;)

damientheomen3
Posted: 5/23/2012 at 2:09 AM Reply with quote
Location: New Jersey

Dialidol has PP ahead. This is looking good so far! (but I believe we're only a little bit into the west coast voting window, so that could change, but I doubt it)

1 2 3 ... 4 next › last »

Subscribe


s