Random Idol Thoughts

Posted by Professor Chan on Friday, April 25, 2008 at 9:32 AM EDT
Share:

Random Idol Thoughts.


-- Two days later and it is STILL funny.  I was convinced that Syesha was going home.  I stood up and cheered when The Plant bit the dust.  That was awesome. 

-- Every time a favorite goes home early and someone stays after a terrible performance, it just validates everything we stand for at VFTW.  If this show was really about giving the best performance week after week then Brooke or Jason goes home, no questions.  Plantson gave one of her best performances Tuesday, so naturally she goes home. 

-- I read excerpts from the Plant’s exit interview and she’s still spinning her webs of lies and B.S.  She blames the backlash from her past hurting her on Idol.  She says that she was only 15 and so she doesn’t even count it as a music career.  Plantson also said that her album failed because “it got no promotion.”  WHAT?!?!?  What delusional world is she living in?  She got $2 million dollars of promotion.  All of her psychotic rationalizations make my head hurt, so I’m done talking about her.  Unless she does anything embarrassing, then I’ll talk about her.


--Goddamn you Simon Cowell for unleashing ANOTHER Mariah Carey clone on the world, Leona Lewis.  The main problem with Mariah Carey music, aside from her coloratura in an ear-splitting register is her insipid songwriting and lame material the last 10 years.  See, Leona Lewis is young, pretty, not yet crazy and she sings just like MARIAH.  I’m sure Simon gets a stiffy every time she hits a high C.  


-- From Leona Lewis’ “Bleeding Love”


But I don't care what they say

I'm in love with you

They try to pull me away

But they don't know the truth

My heart's crippled by the vein

That I keep on closing

You cut me open and I

Keep bleeding

Keep, keep bleeding love


This has Clive Davis’ greasy fingers of crappy song-engineering all over it.  Another soulless lost love ballad about an imaginary relationship, but this time with the cutter imagery of opening a vein and bleeding love all over the place.  Gross.  Is this supposed to be romantic or sexy?  


And who are the people that:  “They try to pull me away, but they don’t know the truth”?  Nobody gives a crap who you’re boning, honey.  NOBODY is trying to pull you way.  The truth is that it is all FAKE.  It is not about REAL emtions.  There is no REAL PERSON that she’s talking about in this song.  


-- It would be awesome if some Death Metal band did a cover of that song.  


-- A quick youtube search shows that Leona won that X Factor show singing the lamest, most banal diva songs possible.  “All By Myself”, “Somewhere Over The Rainbow”, “I Have Nothing”, “A Moment Like This” the deathly terrible winning song from Idol Season 1.  Oh, and of course “Lady Marmalade.”  Why do little girls love to sing the song about becoming a whore?  Oh, right.  Practice for their music career.


-- There are rumblings that the Producers will fiddle with the show format next season to try to stop the ratings slide, because adding musical instruments, bringing in Professional Ringers and having two Beatles Nights really powered the ratings this season, right Nigel?  


Of course, I have a few ideas.


1. Fire Randy and Paula and bring in someone with ACTUAL MUSICAL KNOWLEDGE!  Pick any random record producer and maybe,  say, A VOCAL COACH.  Or better yet, bring in a chimpanzee.  A chimpanzee makes funny faces and throws poo.  That’s an IMPROVEMENT over these buffoons.


2. Cut down the horrible singing weeks to a single Two Hours of Bad Singing show.  Then have several GOOD singing shows, to promote the talent that we will be watching for the next 15 weeks of the season.  Just an idea.  


3. Bring back the Hollywood weeks.  The behind the scenes cat-fighting and bitchiness really shows what kind of jerks these people are, so then we know who to hate and to root against going into the Final 12.  


4.  Have a Duet Night.  The contestants would square off and try to out-sing each other.  That would be awesome and it would force these boring schmoes to get out of their safety zone and really go for it.


5.  This will never happen because of the vast amounts of money involved with two (and even three) nights of programming each week…. But GET RID OF THE HORRIBLE RESULTS HOUR.  Just do what every other singing show on TV does and announce the losers the following week.  “Thanks for showing up but you DON’T GET TO SING this week.”  Because they sucked, you know.  So we don’t want to hear them sing again.


6. And finally, the person with the most votes each week gets to hit Simon in the nuts with a ballpeen hammer.  I’m talking RATINGS!!!


What are your suggestions on how to improve this show?  Let me know.


--Chan


 

1 2 3 ... 9 next › last »
kmantoni
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 9:51 AM Reply with quote
Location: Winchester, VA

Number 6 is a winner!! I think I'd audition just for the slim chance that I'd be able to do that!

I like the results shows for one reason...the cheesy group sing! Especially this year with the stellar dance stylings of one Jason Castro! Love Him!!

One more thing, I'M FIRST!!!! LOL

Kazyan
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 9:52 AM Reply with quote
Location: Nowhere

The duet idea is the best idea I have yet heard on this site.

I think the results show should be cut down to a half hour, but not removed completely. That way we have time to celebrate.

Don't get rid of the crap judges, but have a guest judge every once in a while. Idol can't survive without all three judges.

RadiantBlur
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:02 AM Reply with quote
Location: Oregon

I've been thinking that I'd love to see them do duets, too. It would actually be interesting.

Numbers 2 and 3 are good, too.

woodrow12
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:02 AM Reply with quote
Location: Principal's office

I love all of your suggestions. I really missed all the drama of Hollywood week and the cat fights this year. I would stop the hour long elevator then chair skit. Most of the time you do not know the people they are letting through and it is a waste of time. I wish they would give all the top 24 equal time. I hated the theme nights when there were 24 contestants. I think they do not need to start themes until the top 12. I totally agree the results shows are painful to watch, except last week. I did not watch it until I logged on to VFTW ,and heard the worster news. Jason and Brooke stole the show and the plant went home.

Scott Baio
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:07 AM Reply with quote

My suggestions to improve the show:

1. Add outrageous fictional theme weeks to the mix. For example, remember the Muppet Babies? Well, let's have Idol Babies! The format of the show stays the same, except it's animated, and the judges and contestants all voice animated, precocious infant versions of themselves. Ryan gets to make lots of jokes about Simon pooping his diapers, and Simon gets to make lots of quips about who spiked Paula's baby bottle with vodka. The possibilites are limitless!

2. Make the contestants sing while the audience pelts them with iPods, Coca Cola, Horton Hears a Who DVDs, and Ford vehicles (keep those advertising crossover dollars pouring in)! Anyone left alive and unbruised at the end of the night doesn't get eliminated.

3. Bring Chan's "Caged Death Match" battle of the Idol seasons to life. Construct a huge Thunderdome-style set, and bring back past contestants to compete head-to-head with new "talent." Tina Turner can be a guest judge. The loser must spin the wheel and meet their fate (possible fates include being tied to a donkey and sent into the desert wearing a huge plastic head, having to drive a diversionary fuel tanker through a pack of roving psychos in a post-apocalyptic hell, and having to be Paula Abdul's personal drug mule).

4. Assign psycho stage dads to every contestant. I'm talking Hitler/Jeffrey Dahmer/Ted Bundy type psychos! Any contestant not dead at the end of the season becomes a winner.

5. Replace the judges with real talent. People who actually know a thing or two about music. Replace Randy Jackson with Flava Flav, replace Paula Abdul with Debbie Gibson, and replace Simon Cowell with Rick Astley. Oh, wait, that would basically be the same panel of judges, wouldn't it? Forget number 5!

Mr_Glass
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:15 AM Reply with quote
Banned Location: NYC

Agree that Leona Lewis is just another robot with zero emotion, she makes Carrie Underwood sound like a passionate artist.

About your suggestions:

- "bad singing" auditions are the highest rated episodes, some people like the trainwrecks, so they won't do it

- duets are a great idea, I am surprised they never tried that

- firing the judges will have to happen at one point if they want the show to go on, but Simon will probably leave the show in two years

The most obvious suggestion to increase the ratings after this horrible season is to allow greater song choice for the contestants, and more current themes than 50's, Beatles, ALW etc...

woodrow12
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:16 AM Reply with quote
Location: Principal's office

Scott, like professor Chan, you make VFTW my favorite place.

JohnnyDrama
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:27 AM Reply with quote
PaPa Fuck B**bs Location: Locked in a thread! Get me out of here!!

here's a winner... "Idol After Hours" their living quarters is set up like Big Brother. They have to compete for the "pimp spot". The loser for the week gets to open the Idol show, guaranteeing them a spot at the bottom! They are allowed to have visitors and we get to hear the whispers and innuendo laden bile spewing from contestants like Carly!

A ratings winner!!

thefunnystone
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:29 AM Reply with quote
Administrator

Best.Professor.Chan.Blog.Ever.

I agree 100%

Ravenbomb
Posted: 4/25/2008 at 10:38 AM Reply with quote
Location: Home is where you're happy

My suggestions:

- Run a high-voltage electric current through the stage at random intervals.

- Lengthen the alloted time for them singing and cut down on the bs in between the performances. Someone trying to cram Bohemian Rhapsody into 90-120 seconds is stupid.

- No more Bohemian Rhapsody.

- Three words: Captain Beefheart Week.

- Stop using that stupid "start zoomed in on a monitor with crappy picture quality, then zoom out to show the stage" camera trick that you use once every fucking week. Just stop. Right now. Or I will break your cameras.

1 2 3 ... 9 next › last »

Subscribe