AI3

Jennifer Hudson

Briana Ramirez-Rial

Lisa Wilson

Jon Peter Lewis

Leah Labelle

Matt Rogers

John Stevens

Jasmine Trias

AI4

Constantine Maroulis

Janay Castine

Mikalah Gordon

Scott Savol

Anthony Fedorov

Carrie Underwood

AI5

Bobby Bennett

Brenna Gethers

David Radford

Kevin Covais

Kellie Pickler

Taylor Hicks

AI6

Antonella Barba

Sundance Head

Sanjaya Malakar

Phil Stacey

LaKisha Jones

Blake Lewis

AI7

Amy Davis

Danny Noriega

Amanda Overmyer

Kristy Lee Cook

Brooke White

Jason Castro

David Archuleta

AI8

Tatiana Nicole Del Toro

Nick Mitchell

Alex Wagner-Trugman

Megan Joy

Scott MacIntyre

Lil Rounds

Matt Giraud

Danny Gokey

Kris Allen

AI9

Haeley Vaughn

Paige Miles

Tim Urban

Siobhan Magnus

Michael Lynche (switched to Casey before voting)

Casey James

Lee DeWyze

AI10

Brett Loewenstern

Rachel Zevita

Paul McDonald

Jacob Lusk

Haley Reinhart

Scotty McCreery

CI3

Cher Maendel

Dave Moffatt

Keely Hutton

Jenn Beaupre

Casey LeBlanc

Suzi Rawn

Rex Goudie

CI4

Chris Labelle

Nancy Silverman

Brandon Jones

Chad Doucette

Tyler Lewis

Craig Sharpe

CI5

Tyler Mullendore

Maud Coussa-Jandl

Naomi-Joy Blackhall

Annika Odegard

Jaydee Bixby

CI6

Mark Day

Mitch MacDonald

Am I forgetting any?

Our own pocket pantheon!

Oh my! Awesome collection there, brilliant work F.A.G.!

Wow, TPTB were working overtime with photoshop on most of those photos!

Should I include VFTW Picks for shows we don't give a fuck about anymore?

That would mean you have to include Boy Shakira/Brittney...

I couldn't find a picture of that fug.

Well here it is as Boy Shakira:

And here it is as Boy Brittney:

Will we ever forgive ourselves?

Absolutely excellent. Especially as n00bies come on board, they may not have a clue about who some of the older contestants that referred to are.

This is an excellent reference tool.

I guess I just feel bad that we don't have a catagory for almost pics.

At least some special place for Montana. Were there any others in previous years that were in a similar position?

You forgot 2:

Keely is understandable, but we should never forget Cher. :icansing

I didn't think we picked anyone during those two weeks!

I even still have the banners. I have all of the banners actually if people want me to post them. I've been uploading all of my old pictures to photobucket in case I ever lost them.

I want to see the ones we did for other shows like Dancing with the Stars and So You Think You Can Dance and Rock Star: INXS.

Here you go, banners from the beginning. There was no website for our first few picks, so the banners start with John Stevens.

American Idol 3:

American Idol 4:

Canadian Idol 3:

(I don't remember if we voted for anyone in group 3... I think we didn't)

Rock Star INXS:

(I have no idea what order these went in )

American Idol 5:

Canadian Idol 4:

American Idol 6:

On the Lot:

America's Got Talent:

Canadian Idol 5:

American Idol 7:

Canadian Idol 6:

American Idol 8:

American Idol 9:

American Idol 10:

BTW, FAG, we never voted for Emily Vinette. People just wanted us to, but we picked Corpsey.

Where is the Kelly Monaco banner? I remember it having a really hootchie picture of her on it.

Wil Seabrook?!?

He was sort of hot.

Daphna Dove was my favourite though.

ROCK THE CASBAH!

Those are all great Dave and FAG!

Perhaps we should have a history test for N00bies and be able to put a % of them in order before you can start a new thread!

Worster citizenship.

Oh that's cool.

ZAYRA!!!!111 Gawd I loved that crazy bitch.

Excellent thread FAG.

Brings back good VFTW memories.

But shouldn't we also include our very very first albeit unofficial VFTW pick - Germany's Alexander from World Idol? We didn't have a site back then but still, maybe we can put him under "honorouable mention" or something.