I'm torn! Everything Tatiana sings sounds the same, but Nathaniel is the most annoying contestant.

looks like this is wrong, no way is Joanna getting through

edit: Wow, I was a fan of her since her album came out, but I would not have let her through after tonight's performance.

When will everyone learn that Worsters are always right? There's about a -2% chance this list is wrong now. We totally spoiled this. VFTW Victory!

It was nothing against the Worsters, it just seems like it should be wrong. Some of those people should not go through.

This show sucks but I still keep watching it.

so my bf called it tonight...do you know who Nate reminds me of? terry from reno 911

http://ccinsider.comedycentral.com/2008/05/19/reno-911-the-best-of-terry/

Uh yea...that was said last week on the message board. Try to keep up, mmmkay?

Does anyone know if Felicia Barton made top 36? One list has her on it and the other doesn't.

She is awesome!

This list is the real one. She doesn't make it. Oh well. Better luck next time. If she wanted to make it, she should have played up to VFTW like the others.

i wonder why they havent shown Von shout (err... i mean "sing") ever since his last shoutfest?

im soo happy Tatiana made it! ai lurrrv hurrr! she's Tatilicious!

My only concern is what annoys me is Tatiana exhibits all the symptoms of someone with a bipolar disorder. I'm a little uncomfortable of them taking advantage of it. I've had to personally deal with this in my family and they'll have a real mess if she goes off the deep end. That's why I'm unlikely to support her. It's fine when it's a borderline personality thing but true full blown mental illness is something not to be toyed with.