It's not a matter of whether the dancers sucked or not, but the kind of critique Nigel offered them. If he'd just said: "oh, you guys are not that good" that would have been OK. But his only complaint was that they were dancing together.

Actually, I think Benji is straight. I'm fine with that, 'cause I hate him and he shouldn't be anywhere near our community. The running joke amongst SYTYCD fans is that the runner-up is always gay, with the exception of the first season (Winner Nick Lazzarini is gay, and actually dated S4 contestant Matt Dorame).

Unfortunately, last year broke this rule, too, as it seems pretty fair to say Twitch isn't gay. Winner Joshua might be....

Is that why simon said a few weeks ago,about "were not the silly little dancing show like next door"...He was dissing on his EX PRODUCER..At 1st I was not sure which dancing show they were talking about,there are SOO MANY nowadays.barrrffff

I think itunes is trying to promote chris allen, obviously, but are they allowed to do this?:

as of right now on the itunes home page, they show the top ten songs as normal, having two chris allens in the top 10. no adam lambert at all. "Kiss a girl" by keith urban is number 9. But if you click on the thing that shows all 100 of the top songs, then it shows adam lamberts performance of mad world being number 9. WTF?

Actually, he was talking about DWTS which does film in studio next door.

I laughed my ass off at that whole performance. My wife called me to watch this. I had Blades of Glory running through my head the whole time. I Was waiting for the crotch hold or the Iron Maiden stunt. Friggen hilarious.

I don't agree with that pigheaded judge. They should have been allowed to continued, if for no other reason other than comedic value. Who cares if they are gay. Aren't most dancers on that show gay?

hahahah just read the tweet comments. since when is male dancing not effeminate. Guys want to drink beer and watch women dance with each other, in the vain hope that the women might make out with each other.

Nigel doth protest too much. He's got to be a closet Queen. And that faux mullet hair is way beyond his age. Between him and screaming Mary Murphy on So You Think You Can Dance-they are both so irritable it's difficult to stay with the series. Mia Michaels is the ony decetn choreographer. Nigel looks so burned out and gross. It's probably because he knows all too well the cliche, "No one loves you when your're old and Gay."

being the cocksucking pillow biter that i am , i agree with the not licking or like ing effeminate boys . male dancers should be strong and masculine . most of the boys on sytycd are obviously gay , but moreso masculine in there dance . these two boobs were not good dancers at all . they actully fell down during there performance.. oh and the 34288 is saying he is str8 ! i saw him heard him and watched him sache around backstage and that boy is more of a priss than marsha mellows . get over it VFTW time for the new manly gay to take centert stage ! for all you haters: MUSSEL IT CUJOS

"thanks moxie

nigel looks like a lil fairy queen prancing around with that big stick"

LOL, had no idea Nigel was straight because I always thought he was a BIG fairy queen prancing around with a LIL stick!