I hate her and I'd hate her even more as a temp judge.

they already have one bitchy british person on this show, they don't need another.

katy perry would be alright though, at least shes funny. still going to miss pauler though.

Oh yeah, my friend and I heard this on the radio earlier today. Katy Perry's also gonna judge.

Reality is fading away...

For my money, If "Idol" wants to get a 4th judge for a lot less than $10 million per year, they should send a letter off to Olivia Newton-John. She still has likeability, is fondly remembered for her hits, is attractive, and knows a lot about making it in the music business.

Olivia Newton-John wouldn't create enough controversy. In the words of Betty Rizzo all those years ago - "She's too pure to be Pink". They need another train wreck. How about Diana Ross (if she's still drinking) or Dionne Warwick (if she's still tokin')?