She has a decent voice, but I've just never liked her. There's something about her that puts me off.

I read that article about when she met Mick Jagger, and she came off as totally self centered. My god, what an ego. She probably does believe that the company imploded, rather than that she just couldn't make it.

She pissed me off right from the start when I heard about her "immigration" issues. I would not be surprised if she is not continuing her lying ways by committing "marriage fraud" too.

Perhaps you didn't understand the whole part about supporting those who the producers are not trying to ramrod down America's throat. Go back and read the intro about why VFTW is doing what it is doing.

OMG.....randy needs to stick his head further up Carly's ass....now paula is adding herself to the mix...wonder what Simon will say....week after week so far I think you have choosen the wrong song, until now.....this reminds me 6 years ago of Kelly Clarkson................WHAT A LOAD OF CRAP!!!!! she stank..of course with her background she knew how to preform and make the song happen the way that she was trained and given pointers on.....also you can add another lie to her growing list of them. In her "personal interview" she said that she moved her 3 years ago..didn't she have a problem getting a visa so that she could try out for Idol last year??????? also didn't she say for quite sometime that she works in a tatoo shop?? that wasn't mentioned. Guess you are more crediable if you are a working waitress...boy talk about disrespecting that field of work. No votes from me tonite for the planed one.

I honestly believe that Carly could FART the Alphabet and the judges would rave about it!

Oh Carly...... that was the most melodic fart I have ever heard. We could release that FART tomorrow and it would be a hit single.... YADA, YADA, YADA........

I FEEL SOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH BETTER NOW!!!!

You know, I just actually listened to 'I'm Gonna Blow Your Mind' for the first time, because, well ... call me crazy, but I like singing, I like 18 year old girls, and I'm also a big fan of blowjobs.

Problem was, I don't think the song was actually -about- blowjobs. That's just a cover. A cop-out. That song is so much more hard-core than just being an 18-yo singing about blowjobs.

This is an 18 year old girl singing about anal fisting.

Think about the lyrics:

"I’m trusting you / I know you’d never hurt me baby / So get me a little sure / So let your hands touch me so fine /

Where the sun don’t shine / Boy slow down / Stop"

Wake up and smell the astroglide, people!

I personally think this is the perfect reason to vote for her if she makes it near the end.

Dave,

Out of all the articles you have written, this is a brilliant one! This story needs more exposure by the major news networks.

Dave, your resourcefulness is awesome.

What a lying bitch. I can't believe she's stooping so low to blame 9/11 for her musical inability.

The worst is sorta "who would mock the show the most by thier continued presence" if I understand it correctly.

But sense I take it many people here watch the show, we want to be entertained, so someone bad who is funny to watch and will sass the judges trumps someone boring in the singing and personality departments.

Perhaps it should be "vote for the most ridiculous"