AGREED! Thanks to that Kristy Lee Cook survived and the rest is history. Maybe this can help Tim? Doubt it as it isn't official (or as scandolous as stripping for cash to middle aged men). Time will tell.

I personally say no he isn't gay, though I admit Imy gaydar isn't all that good.

Okay get over your slef he is not gay and btw thats not even gino he is not wearing a hat! He is my coi=usin gino is and btw CASEY IS NOT GAY SO GTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

STUPID

You all are gay if your calling casey gay so what if My COUSIN IS GAY -Gino-yea thats right he's my cousin and so yea get over yourselves i mean seriously we are all a little gay on the inside so yall can just go die in a hole if you be dissing on gays caue there just people everyone always ove reacts so what if casey has a gay hairdresser that does not mean he's gay and gino is not afraid to admit hes gay and mite i remind you hes my cousin and I am not lying so just GTH I SWEAR TO GOD ITS ALL A RUMOR IF YOU BELIVE IN RUMORS YOU ARE GAY!

I don't think I'd be surprised really if James were to be gay, but it would be the shock of the season for sure. Aaron obviously is and I'd be willing to bet Dewyze has hooked up with guys, though not regularly and not with his butt buddy Andrew (he and Timmy seem like major homophobes). From the girls, I would not be surprised at all if Siobhan is at least bi and Bowersox has definitely done it with a chick. Speculation is fun!

One, this picture is old (look at Casey's hair). Two, is it just me, or does he look a bit uncomfortable in this picture? Three, don't the Facebook comments just seem a little too obvious? I smell a setup. I'm thinking he's NOT gay.

On a side note, I thought the same thing about the box and his "before he goes on stage" ritual. Shouldn't he have spilled the beans by now?

I don't think so. Event though Im not much of a fan, he would have a hotter bf then that. Unless the guy is very rich or endowed.. I guess we need more info - get to work