Which American Idol 9 Contestant is Going Home in the Top 9?

It would be pretty fucking hilarious if it was Katie, but I think Aaron. The only contestants worth keeping on the show are Crystal and Casey.

I personally hope Tim is safe, and if so, I'd like to see Aaron go. Andrew has so much more VFTW potential than Aaron, so I'd rather be entertained. Plus the Andrew caricature would be priceless.

I actually think Tim has a shot at being safe. And Aaron is super boring.

I really hope Tim is safe... and would personally be amused if he didn't even have to be in the bottom three (hollah to VFTW peeps if that happens!!).

I think it's Andrews time to go... which would likely upset his luvah Lee.

I don't really agree Andrew has the personality for a VFTW candidate. he bores me. so does lee though... what's with people saying he's original and unique? I hear the same voice in any local bar. i'd be ok with Lee being a VFTW idol but I love Tim's laid back personality and find his "whatever" attitude quite endearing.

That Randy Travis mini me has got to go.

I would like to see Katie or Andrew go, but I have a bad feeling that it's going to be Tim hitting the road. His performance last night was far from his worst, but it wasn't stand out in any way, good or bad. plus simon gave him the "it was well done" so/so critique. It wasn't the best or the worst. Forgettable. He was riding on the disrepect of the judges into last night's episode, and pretty much lost that momentum with their lame comments. TPTB don't want him here any longer, and they've been doing the show for enough years that they know exactly how to play it to get someone booted

This is gonna be an unpredictable week. I'm crossing my fingers for a surprise Casey elimination. If Aaron goes, an undeserving competitor is sent packing. If Tim goes, the internet explodes and I get to watch. If CASEY goes, it's the best of both worlds. So down with Goldilocks!

Trouble is, the judges would probably get stupid and use the save on him.

I really feel that our lil' Timmeh is safe.

But, what the sneaky judges did last night, BARF-tossing him all of that gag-glittery-FAKE-cherry-on-top-of-his performance was cruel, even for them. And, ANYONE who voted their asses off for Tim should be proud of themselves for standing up to the AI TPTB, (especially the Worsters that saw through every rotten layer of their faux cotton candy bullshit.)

It was almost like watching a horror film!

I was screaming at the screen, "NO! Timmeh, don't believe ANYthing they are saying! Voters, they are just trying to lure you into thinking that he is safe so you won't vote for him.

I still cannot believe that for TWO solid hours, I was able to vote my ass off, non-stop, with not even 1 busy signal.

I still say, SOMEhow, SOME way, AT&T aka (satan) has once again, rigged the phone lines..*cough* Arkansas, *cough*Kris Allen who? lol.

And, I think, that is SO sad too. Is AI REALLY that scared of the mighty power of this lil' ole' website, VFTW?

Hmm, obviously so. And, they SHOULD be too.

AI has jumped the shark, and every other ocean critter, and is hanging onto their crap ratings, and their craptastic sorry-assed excuse of a reality show with all 10 of their itty bitty claws.

Once, a great scary monster of a show, they are now nothing but an insignaficent whisper.

The AI Emperor has no clothes on, and finally, The world is noticing.

I think/hope Aaron will be leaving. That performance was beyond forgettable last night, plus being in the death spot and all. I get that his voters are tweens and they are text-crazy, but perhaps enough are on spring break at Disney this week that they won't take the time. A bonus would be that the judges will not bother to save Aaron, but I think they would save either Andrew or Katie.

I think Andrew or Katie is going home. People who vote that Tim is leaving makes SSF cry. *sniff*

I agree that Andrew has VFTW potential. He has big poofy hair, and an ugly neck tattoo. He is a one trick pony and the trick isn't very good. Best of all his dad thinks he should be a janitor.