Brooke sucks, no doubt about it--no range, and while her voice is pleasant it is not meant for this kind of competition. And she's kind of awkward and goofy. But I don't get the extrapolation to imply that she's unstable. Yeah she cries, so what. So has Carly. So has David Cook. I think Brooke cries less than Carly. She cried a lot during the auditions and the hollywood round IIRC but the amount of crying she has done in the finals is less than some of the others.

So, where does the crazy talk come from?

She's not and you know it. It's this kind of thing that can scar her (and other contestants) for life. I hope she doesn't here about what is said about her here. I don't fault her at all for being emotional or nervous. I bet the others are just as nervous and emotional, they just show it a different way.

I fucken love this pick! Let the chops begin!!!

^^^^^^... the crazy talk comes from her!!! We report.. you decide!!!

I wish the pick was Carly, but I will say I love Brook, and whatever gets her to the Top 2 with Archuleta is fine by me.

>Brooke White is the New VFTW Pick

You have done well, Lord Vader. :P

the funny thing is that i like everyone left...besides syeshia...so now that you guys are voting for brooke you basically lost last week

Wow. Everytime I saw the polls, Jason was in the lead.

Awesome =D

Sweet. The "best season ever" is actually giving us a few ripe picks. A mentally unstable IBW, a dreadhead stoner with a uke, a fat lying failure...this is actually pretty nice now that we're in the homestretch.

>when you guys treat them the same if not worse.

You cannot be serious. Are you actually comparing a frivolous little web site to a corporate behemoth that thinks nothing of the psychic damage done to naive young kids by putting them through a hellish gauntlet for profit and amusement? Now I've seen everything.