I hope that everyone who wants to vote for ... what's her name? ... oh yeah, Brooke ... doesn't forget her phone numbers. Maybe she'll forget to show up tomorrow night !!!

Wow - that did NOT disappoint! Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse than a Mariah Carey week, they dump this on them. Are they seriously trying to deliberately sabotage these kids?!?

Syesha was the best of the night - but that's because she's an actress (TV commercials etc) and not really a singer. She should never become a recording "artist" - but I suspect Oprah will snatch her up in record time for The Color Purple once Mantasia has had her fill.

David A. was OBVIOUSLY coached through this round. If he came up with that on his own, then my mom's the pope (and she's a Lutheran by the way).

Carly was also helped BIG TIME by Sir Andrew (God that hurts to call him that). I suspect the producers were all set for her to flop with that crummy Phantom song - then Sir. A. goes and ruins the entire thing by forcing her to do a song that at least suits her, even if she still blew it all to pieces! I can hear a collective "OH FUCK" from the producers when that happened! Too funny.

Jason was by far the worst - they hung him out to dry, and he should be going home tomorrow. My God what an idiot - how is it anybody doesn't know Memory came from "Cats"? And what kind of stoned moron doesn't know a show called "Cats" is indeed about felines? Priceless... Writers couldn't script better material than this!

David Cook is a tool. He's just got 'putz' written all over him.

But Brooke. Oh Brooke. Thank you - not only was it a disaster, but it was so entertaining as well! And silenced Paula! I didn't even think that was possible. Poor girl couldn't think of a damned thing to say after that atrocious couple of minutes. Yep - VFTW chose wisely!

But this whole night was a train wreck that only the composer of Starlight Express could possibly be responsible for. Can you say "last choice"? Because surely Sondheim and Schwartz (and a whole slew of other respectable B-way composers) wouldn't touch this show with a 20,000 foot pole. Does anyone know if Sir A. has a new show coming out that needs promoting?

VOTE FOR BROOKE WHITE.......PLEASE LET HER STAY ON A FEW MORE WEEKS!!!!

VOTE FOR THE WORST THE WHOLE NIGHT!!!!!!!!

(forget your words again next week it was great entertainment!!!!!!!!)

I think Seacrest should forget to show up tomorrow...

The show will be so much better off.

Okay, VFTW got it right. Brooke IS the worst. This was about as train-wrecky a show as AI has ever seen. Top 6 and you're STILL forgetting the words??! INCONCEIVABLE! "That's the first time I've forgotten the words..." BULLSHIT! That's the 2nd time she's had to stop and start over! God, that was really bad. It's clear she can't handle any of this. It was so bad, Simon was extra nice to her. Worst top 6 ever.

No way. Jason got the most votes to be voted for. I'm doing this democratically :-P

I'd do him as well. And I ain't no woman. He's hot.

Oh hell yeah. Me too.

My Jebus, that's good photoshopping...

Wow, Syesha probably just saved herself for another round - good to see her actually enjoying herself on stage for a change.

Andrew Lloyd Webber is getting less creepy as he ages...usually it's the other way around. But I actually liked him...

I definitely agree that Brooke is VFTW material after tonights performance, but Jason is, too! Besides them, I can't picture anyone else as great VFTW material, so I'd say we all should vote for both of them! I actually prefer Jason. I would love to see him high as a kite in the finale.