Heyyyyyy, Phil Stacy talking trash about VFTW???!?? WTF??!? He keeps GOING with his Nosferatu look and he's mad at US for pointing it out? Can you get his stupid banners for his stupid Christian rock album taken off the site, Dave? I think that was rude (and stupid, don't forget stupid) of him. And I think that Fox screwed up who founded the site on purpose because they don't like Dave at all.

When Sanjaya comes out with his album, I'm going to give it to everyone for Christmas.

love, J-Mo

"Evil masterminds??"

For an insignificant little website that's not relevant to AI, DAY-UM we're good!

And can we take Phil Stacey's banner off the site since we're so negative and mean-spirited? We're the only ones making his hypocritical ass relevant.

<p>

What was up with Super-Duper Announcer Guy?  "Remember THIS Guy?"  "They're the wannabe Idols that you LOOOove to hate."  I thought it was supposed to be a NEWS program, not a Demolition Derby/Moto-Cross Promo... "Sunday, SUNDAY, Sunday"?

</p>

<p>

Also, why is Phil complaining about no constructive criticism on our site?  Are we not supposed to comment on the attrocious group dance numbers, Pauler's ineptitude and the horribly biased judging?  Are we just supposed to let the entire show wash over us like a luxuriant wave of crap and meekly sniff at the stench of Music Industry Whore-dom that is Idol?

</p>

<p>

 I told Phil to pick interesting songs and NOT be boring?  And he's ignored BOTH of those brilliant suggestions.  Man, Idol really brainwashes these people, doesn't it?   I like Carly's dead stare and robotic "theyaretoonegativewedonotgotothatwebsite.  Simon is our lord and saviour.  We will do anything for you, Simon."

</p>

<p>

&;nbsp;

</p>

<p>

--Chan 

</p>

News is now "newsertainment." Dumb anchor voices and awful jokes..

Yay Insane! That was awesome. A victory in itself! :D

Insane is so hot

Loved the whole bit except im kinda pissed at Phils comments since him and his wife do post here.

That video made me miss Sanjaya so much

ALl respect I had for that Penis with fangs is out the window now.

F U Phil.

Yes, I loved Carly's corpse-like devil stare... because you know damned well she's read every word on here about her, and she's pissed as hell... because people found out about it.

Oh, and you bet Carly's not gonna say or do anything to admit or acknowledge all her lies, especially since this was, what?... her fifth or sixth chance at having a "successful non-imploding singing career"?

Phil is total tool, and I hope he winds up on tour with the John Hagee Family Singers, who will chase him all over the place trying to throw holy water on him and cast him back into hell where he belongs...

love, J-Mo

Yeah, I like how he badmouths VFTW (voteforthestoned) yet stil tries to peddle his bullshit CD all over the site. Fuck off Stacula!

You guys kinda proved Phil's point, you know.

The old contestants just aren't admitting that they look at this site.

When I first came here lurking I thought this was mean spirited too. Now I feel like its just a place for people to get out their frustrations about the bad performances and how unfair AI in the first place. Before when I read about how someone hated a contestant I was like "DAYUM!, that was harsh" now I don't think its harsh at all and the meanness is directed mostly at AI. Personally I get sick to death of a contestant not trying to get better every week and the fact that the show doesn't help them get better. AI already knows who they want to win so helping the other contestants improve could mess up their plan for the winner. The contestants are on the results show on Thursday, and all day the next Wednesday is rehearsing for the actual show. That leaves five days for them to make a commercial, do appearances (like spending a day in Vegas), learn a silly group song and dance routine, and learn and prefect a new song in a style in which they probably aren't any good. If they want constructive criticism they sure aren't going to get it from Paula "You look beautiful" Rehabdul, or Randy "I worked with Mariah Carey Dawg" Jackson, and Simon "my hamburger is missing the meat" Cowell. I've read plenty of constructive criticism here not just for the contestants but for the show in general (like stop using plants.)

Anyway I agree with pulling the Phil Stacey ad. I'm sure they aren't allowed to come out and say they love VFTW but still, he could have just said "I don't look at that site."