If this was Carly, she would have said something about never singing the song before.

OMG if you play them together they are almost exactly the same ... Down to the final screeching notes.

How much did she really have to practice that one?

Seriously, was Jason and Kristy the only contestants of the last 8 that never sang on tv or made a record before? amateurs my ass!

Syesha's voice is ssoooo GENERIC that it's soooo BORING!!!!!!!!!!! how the fuck she got that far!! Rickey.org was joking Fanesha 300 Ha-ooh Ha-ooh Ha-ooh. god, that's funny! she'd better go home! i don't like all three songs she sang tonight! generic and not unique at all! who is she as an artist?? she's just a technically good singer, that's all. but she's not my style of music, and if i turn on the radio and hear her song, i wouldn't even know that it's sung by her as her voice is the same as 123232465465446452344123113246 other diva singers out there. i miss Brooke and Jason. esp Brooke. she should be there with her unique and refreshing style. even DC is not unique and refreshing as there are Bo and Daughtry before him. but i'm glad she didn't win, as her album Songs From The Attic are doing very well on the itunes chart now. you guys should check it out!

I have no need for insomnia therapy, Miknge.

Zaza,

Kristy made a record awhile back in Nashville. It tanked. Out of the top 10 Chikezie, and Jason were probably the least experienced professionally. Funny that, I liked both of them much more than I like the current top 3. If you had to break down the entire top 12? There were a helluva lot of plants in there. Check out the article in VFTW's Greatest Hits. Even Brooke recorded a CD prior to Idol.